Jungle House Phuket
฿ Rate1 ฿ = $0.029|1 ฿ = €0.027|🌦️28°C|PHOODIE 2026 comes to Phuket: ten days worth leaving your usual restaurant for
investment
9 min read
August 6, 2026

Yield up to 18% per year: a real investment or a marketing number?

Viktor Garmashov
Viktor Garmashov
Independent broker in Phuket · 10+ years · 150+ deals
Доходность до 18% годовых: реальная инвестиция или красивая цифра в рекламе?
Our Telegram channel
@junglehousethai

Imagine: a seaside apartment, a professional management company, and a yield of up to 18% per year.

It sounds like an investment where everything comes together — real estate preserves capital, tourist flow secures tenants, and the owner receives passive income. That is exactly why offers with double-digit yields attract so much attention.

Recently, we were invited to add a property to our portfolio with a stated yield of up to 18% per year. We could have simply put that figure into an ad — and most likely received a lot of enquiries.

But we chose not to.

Not because 18% is impossible. Such a result genuinely can be achievable in the right scenario. The problem is different: between the words "yield up to 18%" and the actual money the owner receives in their account, there can be a big gap.

Let's break down how to read offers like this, which questions to ask the developer, and how to tell a financial model apart from a marketing promise.


Why the figure "up to 18%" guarantees nothing on its own

The first thing to notice is the word "up to".

It marks the upper boundary of a possible result — not the guaranteed income of every owner. The actual yield could be 18%, 12%, or 7% — it all depends on the assumptions behind the calculation.

Sometimes the figure in the ad is based on real operating statistics. But it can also be derived from the most favourable scenario:

  • the property is rented at the maximum rate;
  • occupancy stays high almost all year;
  • the owner's costs are minimal;
  • the property's value rises as forecast;
  • the planned profit is actually realised on resale.

Each condition on its own can be realistic. The probability that all of them happen at the same time, however, is considerably lower.

So the right question is not:

"Can 18% be achieved?"

But rather:

"How is the 18% built up, under what conditions is it achievable, and how much actually stays with the owner?"


Which base is the yield calculated on?

Let's say a property costs 10 million rubles and the projected annual rental income is 1.2 million.

Divide the income by the full price of the property and you get a 12% annual yield.

But in the developer's presentation the calculation may be based on the down payment. For example, the buyer pays 3 million up front and the rest in instalments. Then the ratio of annual income to the down payment looks far more attractive.

Such a calculation is not necessarily wrong. But it answers a different question and does not show the yield of the whole investment.

You need to clarify:

  • whether the full price of the property is used;
  • whether the cost of finishing and furniture is included;
  • whether taxes and registration costs are added;
  • whether instalment or loan payments are taken into account;
  • which base the advertised percentage is actually calculated on.

A percentage without a base is just a number. You cannot evaluate an investment from it alone.

Want us to check the yield calculation for a specific property and show you the real base? Leave a request — we'll walk through the numbers together.


Gross yield and net profit are not the same thing

Most often the ad shows gross yield — the full amount a property could theoretically generate before expenses.

For example, an apartment rents on average for 10,000 rubles a day and is occupied 250 days a year.

Potential revenue comes to:

10,000 × 250 = 2,500,000 rubles a year.

But that is not yet the owner's income.

From that amount the following may be deducted:

  • the management company's commission;
  • taxes;
  • utilities;
  • complex maintenance;
  • cleaning and turnover preparation;
  • booking-platform commissions;
  • insurance;
  • repairs and furniture replacement;
  • advertising the listing;
  • building a reserve fund.

After all expenses, instead of 2.5 million the owner might be left with, for example, 1.5–1.8 million rubles.

So investment offers should be compared by net yield — the amount left after mandatory expenses.

It helps to request not only the projected revenue but the full list of costs. If expenses are missing from the calculation, it does not mean they will not exist.

Send us the property presentation — we'll calculate net yield with all costs and taxes.


Is the rental income being combined with capital growth?

One of the most common ways to produce an impressive figure is to add together several different types of potential profit.

For example:

  • 9% — projected rental yield;
  • 6% — expected growth in the property's value;
  • 3% — early-bird discount.

That totals 18%.

Mathematically the sum looks convincing. Economically, though, these are three different indicators.

Rental income is received while you hold the property. Capital growth turns into real money only on sale. An early-bird discount lowers the purchase price but is not annual income.

On top of that, capital growth cannot be considered guaranteed. It is affected by market conditions, area development, tourist flow, competition, interest rates, and the liquidity of the specific property.

If the property's value rose 10% on paper but there is no buyer at that price, the owner has not yet made a profit.

So when analysing an offer it is important to separate:

  1. rental income;
  2. change in market value;
  3. one-off discounts and bonuses;
  4. potential profit on resale.

Only then does it become clear which part of the advertised 18% can flow to the owner regularly and which part exists only as a forecast.


What occupancy is built into the financial model?

The income of resort property depends directly on occupancy — the number of days the property is occupied by guests.

But occupancy is rarely the same all year round.

In high season demand may be close to maximum. In low season an apartment can sit empty for weeks or months. The result is also influenced by weather, transport accessibility, competition, regional events, and management quality.

Pay particular attention to calculations that simultaneously assume:

  • high occupancy almost all year;
  • the maximum nightly rate;
  • no gaps between bookings;
  • minimal costs;
  • no unplanned repairs.

Such a scenario is possible, but using it as the sole basis for an investment decision is risky.

A sound financial model should include not one forecast but at least three:

Conservative scenario

Occupancy and nightly rate come in below expectations, while costs run slightly higher than planned.

Base scenario

Average, realistic figures are used for occupancy, rates, and costs.

Optimistic scenario

High demand, a strong season, and property value growth match the forecast.

If the investment looks attractive only in the optimistic scenario, the risks deserve extra attention.

Request a financial model with three occupancy scenarios for the property you are interested in.


Who guarantees what, exactly?

The word "guaranteed" in advertising makes a strong impression. But what matters is not the wording in the presentation — it is the content of the contract.

You need to understand:

  • which company commits to making payouts;
  • how long it has been operating;
  • where the money for payouts comes from;
  • whether the obligation is legally binding;
  • whether the amount, percentage, and timeline are specified;
  • whether liability for delays is provided for;
  • whether there are conditions under which payouts can be reduced or cancelled;
  • whether a bank guarantee or other security is offered.

It is especially important to distinguish between two models.

In the first, the management company pays the owner a fixed amount regardless of actual occupancy. Then you need to assess the reliability of the company itself and its ability to meet its obligations.

In the second, the owner receives a share of the property's actual income. In that case the result depends on occupancy, rates, and costs.

Both models can work. The key is that the buyer understands which model they are being offered.

A manager's phrase "we guarantee the yield" does not replace the corresponding clause in the contract.


Which costs stay with the owner?

Sometimes a high yield is achieved simply because part of the costs is not included in the advertised calculation.

After purchase, additional expenses may appear:

  • furnishing and equipping the apartment;
  • an entry fee to the management programme;
  • a monthly commission;
  • utilities and operating charges;
  • property tax;
  • tax on rental income;
  • insurance;
  • routine and capital repairs;
  • interior refreshes;
  • fixing damage after guests;
  • the property sitting idle during repairs.

It is important to find out not only the size of each payment but how it can change. For example, the management company's commission may be 20% today, but the contract allows the rate to be revised.

A good financial model accounts not only for the obvious first-year costs but for expenses across the whole holding period.

Send us a request — we'll review the management contract and show you all hidden costs.


What happens after the programme ends?

Some enhanced or guaranteed-yield programmes run only for a limited time — for example one, two, or three years.

At launch the developer or management company may top up owners' payouts to make the offer attractive and get the property going. Once the programme ends, payouts move to a market model.

So make sure you clarify:

  • how many years the advertised yield lasts;
  • whether the percentage stays the same for the whole period;
  • whether the management company can change the terms;
  • how income will be calculated after the programme ends;
  • whether you can change the management company;
  • whether there are restrictions on renting it out yourself;
  • what the terms are for an early exit;
  • how easy it will be to sell the property.

An investment does not end after the first year. It is important to understand in advance how the property will perform in three, five, and ten years.


How a single figure can hide several assumptions at once

Imagine a property priced at 12 million rubles.

The presentation advertises a yield of up to 18%. But after studying the calculation it turns out the figure is made up of:

  • 9% — gross rental yield at high occupancy;
  • 5% — projected capital growth;
  • 2% — benefit from an early-bird discount;
  • 2% — potential profit on a successful resale.

That comes to 18%, but the owner will not receive this sum annually into their bank account.

Gross rental yield must be reduced by expenses. Capital growth remains a forecast until the sale. The discount is given once. And resale profit depends on future demand.

As a result, the regular net yield can turn out to be significantly lower than the advertised figure.

That does not mean the property is bad. It may be in a promising location, highly liquid, and capable of generating good income.

But the decision should be made on the real structure of profit, not on a sum of indicators with different natures.


Seven questions to ask before buying

If you are offered a property with a high yield, request the financial model and ask seven questions:

  1. Which base is the percentage calculated on?
  2. Is it gross or net yield?
  3. Which costs are already included and which does the owner pay?
  4. What rates and occupancy are built into the forecast?
  5. Does the percentage include capital growth of the property?
  6. Who is legally responsible for payouts and where is that recorded?
  7. What happens after the yield programme ends?

The more specific the answers, the easier it is to evaluate the offer.

If instead of calculations you are shown only beautiful photos, tourist-flow growth, and a large percentage on the first slide, there is not yet enough information for an investment decision.

Send us the developer's presentation — we'll ask all these questions for you and come back with answers.


Signs of a transparent investment offer

A property's reliability cannot be judged from a single figure. But there are signs of a more professional approach:

  • a detailed financial model is provided;
  • income and costs are shown separately;
  • there are several scenarios, not only the optimistic one;
  • payout terms are fixed in the contract;
  • the management company's track record is verifiable;
  • occupancy statistics are backed by data;
  • risks are not hidden but explained;
  • the buyer is given time to study the documents;
  • the manager can explain where every figure comes from.

A transparent offer does not have to promise the highest percentage. Its advantage is different: the investor understands exactly how their money will work.


Does that mean an 18% yield is impossible?

No.

In a well-chosen property, with high occupancy, competent management, capital growth, and a favourable market, the combined result really can reach 18% and even exceed it.

But it is important to use precise wording:

"Up to 18% in an optimistic scenario" — a possible forecast.

"18% net annually" — a claim that requires serious calculations and legal guarantees.

Between "it is possible to earn" and "guaranteed to receive every year" lies a huge difference.


Why we did not simply sell a beautiful figure

Our job is not to talk a client into buying a property at any cost.

Investment property has to match their goals, holding period, risk appetite, and income expectations. One buyer cares about regular payouts. Another — about preserving capital. A third — about capital growth and being able to use the property themselves.

So when we see an advertised yield of up to 18%, we first request the calculations and documents:

  • we study the financial model;
  • we check the structure of the yield;
  • we count the mandatory costs;
  • we analyse the management contract;
  • we consider different occupancy scenarios;
  • we assess the exit terms of the investment.

Only after that do we explain to the client what result they can count on in the conservative, base, and optimistic scenarios.

Leave a request for a free review of an investment offer.


Key takeaway

A high yield on its own should neither scare you nor convince you to buy.

18% can be possible in a particular scenario. But a single advertising figure does not show the probability of that result, the costs, the risks, or the parties' legal obligations.

Do not walk away from an attractive property just because the figure is high. But do not make a decision until you understand how it was calculated.

A good investment withstands questions.

And if, after a detailed review, the percentage turns out to be lower but clearer and more realistic, that is not a disappointment. It is the moment the advertising ends and a conscious investment decision begins.


Investor checklist

Before buying, ask the seller to provide:

  • a full yield calculation;
  • a list of owner costs;
  • an occupancy forecast by season;
  • nightly rates;
  • the management contract;
  • the terms of guaranteed payouts;
  • the duration of the programme;
  • the rules for exit and resale of the property.

Save this checklist and use it when comparing investment offers.

Jungle House — helping you choose property based on calculations, not promises.

Want a personal review of an investment property? Leave a request — we'll get back to you.

Get new articles in Telegram - follow the Jungle House Phuket channel

Telegram

Want to discuss investments?

Write to us and we'll find properties to match your budget with an honest return calculation.

Next step — pick a property on this topic

Frequently Asked Questions

Share: